Dev Objects to Guide Remake by MS Ahsan

News

Channels

In Focus

Analysis
Bolography
Cartoons
Environment
Opinion

Columns

Business
My Word
PlainSpeak
Random Thoughts

Our Heritage

Architecture
Astrology
Ayurveda
Buddhism
Cinema
Culture
Dances
Festivals
Hinduism
History
People
Places
Sikhism
Spirituality
Vastu
Vithika

Society & Lifestyle

Family Matters
Health
Parenting
Perspective
Recipes
Society
Teens
Women

Creative Writings

Book Reviews
Ghalib's Corner
Humor
Individuality
Jagoji
Literary Shelf
Love Letters
Memoirs
Musings
Ramblings
Stories
Travelogues

Computing

General Articles
CC++
Flash
Internet Security
Java
Linux
Networking

Advertisement

Boloji Prepaid
International
Calling Cards

Cinema
Remake Rage in Bollywood
Dev Objects to Guide Remake
by MH Ahsan

Evergreen Dev Anand is miffed about reports of Pritish Nandy Communication's remake plans of Guide. He registers his objection through a letter to the producer. A copy is reproduced exclusively for the discerning Boloji reader

Navketan International Films
42, Pali Hill, Zig-Zag Rd.,
Bandra (W), Mumbai - 400 050

March 1, 206

To
Mr. Pritish Nandy,
Pritish Nandy Communications,
87/88, 8th floor, Mittal Chambers,
Nariman Point,Mumbai 400 021.

Dear Pritish,
My attention is drawn to the recent press reports in Midday (issue dated 25/02/06, and The Asian Age (issue dated 1/03/06) that you are attempting to remake the feature film "Guide" produced by me in 1965 as "Rahgir"/Rehguzar" featuring Akshay Kumar, Vidya Balan in the main leads and to be directed by Rituparna Ghosh. These reports have disturbed me no end.

I must inform you that Rituparna Ghosh in an earlier meeting with me, had expressed his desire to remake "Guide". I had categorically opposed and objected to the idea, then. Please be aware that the sole and exclusive copyrights of the feature film "Guide" vest in my company including the filming rights of the original novel "The Guide" written by R K Narayan.

Though in your personal statements you are denying that your new film (tentatively titled "Rahgir/Rehguzar") is a remake of "Guide", it is obvious from the press stories that you are taking advantage of the reputation of my film "Guide" to seek a strong commercial and aesthetic platform to promote your new film. Besides, as Rituparna Ghosh is directing the film, I am inclined to believe that you are actually remaking "Guide".

If any one has the right to remake "Guide" it is only my production Company. Even my Company has taken a conscious decision not to remake "Guide" as I sincerely believe at the risk of sounding immodest, that "classics" cannot be remade I am writing this letter to you urging you to refrain from mentioning my name and/or the name of my film "Guide" in any of the press stories and more importantly also from remaking "Guide". Please be informed that I reserve the rights to claim appropriate damages from you for dragging the name of my film "Guide" in your press stories, for your commercial gains.

Lastly, in spite of this letter, should you chose to continue to use the name of my film "Guide" and/or even attempt to remake "Guide", I am determined to pursue and enforce my rights and seek necessary recovery/damages from appropriate forums, besides instituting appropriate legal proceedings against you/your company, for infringement of my copyrights and all other rights, the consequences and costs of which shall be solely attributed to you. I sincerely trust you will not push me to take this extreme step.

Affectionately yours,

Navketan International Films,
Dev Anand
c.c. to:- The Film Producers' Guild of India, Mumbai.

~*~

Pritish Nandy Clarifies:
Pritish Nandy, in an exlusive interview to M H Ahsan clears the air –

What is your response to the letter of discontent sent to you
by Mr Dev Anand?
The answer is written in his letter, please refer to para no. 3 of the said letter in which he himself clearly says that I have denied that our film is not a remake of Guide. I will really appreciate if he will not waste his time and mine in writing these letters.

He also points out that by not denying false media reports you are trying to get a mileage for your forthcoming production?
What sort of mileage would I get out of such reports? It has been my policy not to respond to media reports unless I have something concrete to say. Otherwise, the media has it's own agenda and i have mine.

Have you signed Akshay Kumar and Vidya Balan for your forthcoming venture?
Akshay Kumar has been signed and Vidya Balan is yet to be confirmed.

Is the proposed venture titled Rahgir?
Yes, that is the working title.

Does the storyline bear any resemblance to Guide?
It is a infidelity tale and no one has the copyright to same.

March 19, 2006

Back to Remake Rage in Bollywood

Top | Cinema

The Week of March 19, 2006
India's Politics on the Boil by Dr. Subhash Kapila
Reforming Criminal Justice by Rajinder Puri
India Aghast at Minority Imperialism by Dr. Subhash Kapila
US History - Lesser Known Facts, Analogies & Surmises Part 6 by Gaurang Bhatt, MD
BJB: Kal Ho Na Ho! by Usha Kakkar
Cartoons Claim Another Victim! by Usha Kakkar
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad : A Revolutionary Journalist by Syed Muzammiluddin
Bheel Mahabharata: Ganga Weds a Frog Prince by Satya Chaitanya
Will the War against Terrorism become Successful? by TA Ramesh
Buddhism and Human Rights in Tibet by Tanmoy Mookherjee
Poisoned Lives: Hyderabad's Stillborn Future by MH Ahsan
Justice is all about Healing the Victims by Manjri Sewak
Lost in Cane... and Twice ... by Naiya Sivaraj
Who Ate my Soulmate? by Neha Girotra
Write, Write and Write ... by Suniti Chandra Mishra
Overcoming Fear by Sugandha Indulkar
Is Your Child Allergic to Milk? by Garima Gupta
Baby Servants of Baba Logs by Malvika Kaul
Premenstrual Syndrome by Dr. Muneeb Faraaz
A Language for Love by Akshay Khanna
IT at Home by Tripat Kaur
Remake Rage in Bollywood by MH Ahsan
    Dev Objects to Guide Remake by MH Ahsan
My Dad Left Holes by Monisha Sen
Who will Pursue Medical Profession? by Dr. Shanker Adawal