Tamil Brahmins: Lost in Tamil Nadu. by G. Venkatesh SignUp
Boloji.com
Boloji
Home Kabir Poetry Blogs BoloKids Writers Contribute Search Contact Site Map Gift Shop Advertise RSS Login Register
Boloji
Channels

In Focus

Analysis
Cartoons
Education
Environment
Going Inner
Opinion
Photo Essays

Columns

A Bystander's Diary
Business
My Word
PlainSpeak
Random Thoughts

India Nest

Architecture
Astrology
Ayurveda
Buddhism
Cinema
Culture
Dances
Festivals
Hinduism
History
People
Places
Sikhism
Spirituality
Vastu
Vithika

Society & Lifestyle

Family Matters
Health
Parenting
Perspective
Recipes
Society
Teens
Women

Creative Writings

Book Reviews
Ghalib's Corner
Humor
Individuality
Literary Shelf
Love Letters
Memoirs
Musings
Quotes
Ramblings
Stories
Travelogues
Workshop

Computing

CC++
Computing Articles
Flash
Internet Security
Java
Linux
Networking
Society Share This Page
Tamil Brahmins: Lost in Tamil Nadu.
by G. Venkatesh Bookmark and Share
 

Years ago, well-known Tamil actor and political satirist Mr Cho Ramaswamy had remarked tongue firmly in cheek – “Tamil Brahmins are people who fight with each other, degrade themselves and paint the entire community in shades of dark.” If you look at the events (in literary and movie circles in Tamil Nadu and the political climate), you will realise that Mr Ramaswamy was absolutely right then, he is right even now.

We talk about Kashmiri Pandits becoming strangers in Jammu and Kashmir. The Tamil Brahmins find themselves alienated in their own land. With more than 75% of the younger generation of Tamil Brahmins having moved to foreign land in pursuit of job / education and others scattered across different parts of India, it is an easy guess that population of Tamil Brahmins in Tamil Nadu is steadily waning. The increasing trend of inter-caste marriages is a further threat.

Let us look at how some of the Tamil Brahmins have defiled themselves:

  • Well known Tamil actor Kamal Hasan leads the pack. At every opportunity, he has prided in calling himself an agnostic, but unfortunately the actor has never shied away from depicting Hindu Gods and Brahmins in poor light in his movies. See the irony of the situation..In the movie “Mahanadi”, Kamalhasan is shown visiting the temple and a song plays in the background – Sri Ranga Ranganathanin padam vandanam solladi” (Bow before the Lotus feet of Lord Ranganatha!)
  • In most Kamal Hasan movies, the lady with the 9-yard saree is a caricature, (Example, in one of his movies, an old lady in a 9-yard saree is shown stealing; in his movie Avvai Shanmughi (the Tamil version of “Chachi 420”), he has shown how the lady in the nine-yard saree unabashedly flaunts her assets and entices men to lust after her.)
  • No one has made mockery of the language used by Brahmins like Kamal Hasan has. His nieces Suhasini Manirathnam and Anu Haasan are not far behind. They consider themselves so progressive that Anu Hasan models for eggs, chicken masala, anything that is considered taboo in a Brahmin society.
  • In the name of exposing age-old traditions in Tamil Brahmin community that were regressive, well-known Tamil novelist  Sivasankari ended up projecting Tamil Brahmins in poor light in some of her novels. She, along with another novelist called Indumathi, wrote a Tamil novel called “Irandu Per” (Two persons) where a bored Brahmin wife is sexually attracted to a photographer (shades of the Bengali movie Paroma perhaps ?).
  • K Balachander of course gets the credit as the director for showing Tamil Brahmins in poor light in the maximum number of Tamil movies and one Hindi movie (Ek Duje Ke Liye, which incidentally featured Kamal Haasan). Remember the hero’s father in Ek Duje Ke Liye who carps endlessly ?
  • In “Arangetram” (1974), Balachander had the gall to compare a Tamil Brahmin girl’s rape with the first dance recital of a Bharat Natyam student. “Arangetram” is the debut on-stage performance of a “Bharat Natyam” student.
  • When it was released, “Arangetram” raised the hackles in Tamil Nadu.The movie was a super hit. However, K balachander failed to recreate the magic in Hindi (the movie “Aaina” featuring Rajesh Khanna and Mumtaz).
  • In “Arangetram”, the protagonist is the eldest of eight siblings. (Kamal haasan is one of them). The protagonist questions her mother as to why she has not adopted methods of family planning and is privy to her mother secretly moving to the kitchen to satiate her husband’s lust. Such a screen play was written by K Balachander in the name of realism. Worse, after her rape, the protagonist decides to become a prostitute to support her   family. In the end, her siblings turn out to be ungrateful and the protagonist loses her sanity.
  • By the way, I am a great fan of Mr K Balachander but find some of his views discordant and more extremist than rational.
  • K Balachander’s daughter married outside the community so may be Balachander was disillusioned with the Brahmin community as a whole and so he chose to depict such scenes on screen that portrayed Tamil Brahmins in poor light.
  • A movie called “Savithri” was released in the mid 80s and then banned. This movie shows a young Brahmin wife (in nine yards) who is forced to marry a man who is much older than her. The protagonist leads a platonic life with her husband, gets frustrated and in the bargain is seduced by an artist who visits the village. In the end, she commits suicide.
  • There was another movie called “Agraharathil kazhuthai” (“A donkey in Brahmin lane”) by director John which I believe won a few awards.
  • The late writer Anuradha Ramanan wrote a story called “Chirai” (Prison) in which a Brahmin wife deserted by her husband after being raped by a Catholic man goes and lives with the Catholic man. When the latter dies, she removes her mangal sutra and leads the rest of her life as the latter’s widow. Progressive thought yes, but why Anuradha chose to show the protagonist as a Brahmin inspite of the fact that so many other communities exist in Tamil Nadu is anyone’s guess. Of course, Anuradha Ramanan was a hardcore Tamil Brahmin.
  • I believe Anuradha went one step ahead and portrayed the wife of a Tamil priest as succumbing to the lecherous glances of another person in her novel “ Kootu puzhukkal” (Worms living in groups).
  • Then you had well known writer Sujatha (Rangarajan) who began writing a serial story in the Tamil Magazine “Kumudam” in the 80s. The story titled as “Black Red White” was centered on the 1857 revolution. Sujatha, in his inimitable style, peppered the story with liberal doses of sex; he made the colossal mistake of naming one of the characters in the novel after one of the non-Brahmin communities in Tamil Nadu. Within two weeks, Sujatha (who lived in Bangalore at that time) received death threats and phone calls that his hands would be chopped off. Copies of the magazines were burnt by the said community with the threat that if publication of the serial continued, the editorial office would be burnt to ashes. The serial was stopped abruptly. The magazine and the writer   profusely apologised for hurting the sentiments of the community. Much later, Sujatha rewrote the novel as “Rattam Orey Niram” (Blood is of  the same colour).
     
  • One more Tamil Brahmin who wrote under the pseudonym “Hema Anandatheerthan” wrote such vulgar novels which were pure pulp fiction. His protagonists were mostly Brahmin girls who lusted after men.

Thus, three factors contributed to degradation of Tamil Brahmins in Tamil Nadu.

• Negative influence of movies
• Negative influence of Tamil literature
• The Dravidian rule in Tamil Nadu

Ask any like-minded Tamil Brahmin settled abroad or settled in other parts of India, whether he would like to relocate to Chennai. The answer would be a strict no. Chennai auto drivers are notorious but they are particularly harsh on Tamil Brahmins. Some of my cousins who studied in Chennai have shared anecdotes of how they were ragged for speaking the Brahmin language.

A Malayalee will always support a Malayalee, but a Tamil Brahmin, will always work against other Brahmins. The people whom I have mentioned in the above paragraphs are classic examples. The net result of all these is that Tamil Brahmins are slowly losing their identity in Tamil Nadu.

2010. A village in Tamil Nadu. A street that houses Brahmins called as Agraharam”. Unlike the past, where “Agraharam” was symbolic of “Brahmins”, today  the “Agraharm” is a mere prop. Not a single house in the “Agraharam” belongs to a Brahmin.

 2050. A child born to Tamil Brahmin parents asks his mother, ‘Mother, what is an agraharam?”. The distraught mother promises her child that she will rather take him to the exhibition/ museum, as she herself is unable to answer the question.

15-Sep-2010
More by :  G. Venkatesh
 
Views: 8532
Article Comment ya cho ramasamy was grate legend and sujatha and grazzy
baranitharan iyyengar
05/10/2013
Article Comment I happen to go through the article and comments thereof from many readers. Basically it is the question of thriving and surviving among the competitors and this aspects is widely prevalent in all communities right from Kashmir to Kanyakumari. When education and knowledge is the criteria to further the interests in all walks of life, Brahmins some how or other up in the ladder mainly due to the non-competitiveness from other communities. Unfortunately, this trend was and is in existence. Will any non-brahmin who is rich literally sound willing to have alliance of the same caste who are poor and illiterate? Stray incidents cannot be a yardstick to measure such alienation. The politicians for their own survival keep on castigating Brahmins as their enemies. Cinema also plays an important role for their anti-brahmin propagation. Present day world wants only meritorious people and not on caste line.
R Ganesan
04/27/2013
Article Comment Hi,

I am a non-brahmin. I have two friends. One is a brahmin. thE OTHER IS QUESTIONABLE. But still, I feel inferior. It sucks. tHey are cool. I am not. I eat meat like a savage. tHEY EAT VEGETABLES. I wish i could only eat vegetables. and their sambar is better than mine. And kamal hassan is legit. So don't hate. Brothers. From other non-brahmin mothers. Because we are the real losers. For being so dark. and nasty.
A Fellow Non-Brahmin
03/17/2013
Article Comment I disagree with the thought that Tamil Brahmins are non supportive of each other. This apparent impression is due to the fact that Tamil Brahmins are 'Thinking' people and they seldom react emotionally. To illustrate, a Tamil Brahmin will look at an issue objectively before deciding to take appropriate action. It does not matter to him whether the people involved in a crisis are Brahmins or not. To him, the merits of the case only matters. That is why it is generally felt that a Tamil Brahmin is slow to support a fellow Brahmin because he is not swayed by emotions unlike other communities. that is why when Shankaracharya was arrested there was no large scale uprising in the community as it felt that nobody is above Law and that due process of Law should be obeyed and the Innocence shall be proved. I dont think any other community has that sort of maturity and patience. Tamil Brahmins firmly believe that Two Wrongs will not make a Right. But witness the sikh's anger for the invasion of Gurdwara. But sadly, the Tamil Brahmins solidarity to non violence has been taken to undue advantage by the other communities. Reservation had been hailed as the Great Leveller. But, it has only fractured the Society and today nobody is happy including the depressed classes. Economic Reservation would have made sense. There are only 2 divisions in the Society, the Haves and the Have-Nots. The aim should be to bridge this gap instead of artificially creating a castless society by implementing caste based reservation.
arvind
02/12/2013
Article Comment Excellent Article. Very True - every word. Kamalahassan desrves this hit for Viswaroopam.
Salim Khan
02/02/2013
Article Comment As a non Brahmin from Rajasthan I would further add Brahmins are opportunistic,whether its religion or begging they take advantage of every situation. So its for other communities to decide, "NEVER TRUST THEM". They never sacrificed in my lands, never ever sweat for the earning. They become humble, sit downside and start criticizing the hard working people in front of rulers, gain sympathy and earn livelihood, its the PAST. With Brits they learned ENGLISH, called themselves freedom fighters (only on fingures u can count such freedom fighters numbers). still got PrimeMinister Ship, 14 Chief Ministers in India, innumerable Civil Services Officers.....its called OPPORTUNISM. They are dead against RESERVATIONS, as if they are sons of Charles Darwin. or Newton. THEY KILLED MAHATMA GANDHI. They are RAWAN worshipping RAMA, for their livlihood. RAMA broke the Parshurama's Bow and Lakshmana simply told Parsuram to get lost. But NOW a days they eat non veg, drink wine and still raise their voice for COW protection. Its full advantage of Democracy and Religion. I m sure if required for Monetary gains they can eat COW also. MY HUMBLE REQUEST TO EVERY ONE ON OUR LAND, apart from Brahmins, WE ARE ONE AND ONLY ONE.
Ajaypal Singh
01/30/2013
Article Comment It is true that when a community is insulted, the entire community would unite & stop this non sense. But tamil brahmins will not support their poor cousins. They divide the family on the basis of wealth.

Full of cheaters who would cheat the innocent siblings. I am the best example


Sundar

sundara raman vs
01/03/2013
Article Comment Globally the trend is all communities are merging. It is difficult to live alone sticking on to one language, caste, religion and traditions. Be Happy
Rajagopalan RamaSubramanian
12/21/2012
Article Comment Are we still talking and thinking about caste? You shameless idiot
aks
12/14/2012
Article Comment whatever said is true. Social changes are happening every where. Even caste hindu girls only like dalit boys. Globalisation has created identity crisis every where. Tamils had migrated to South Africa during early 19th century. The great grand sons and daughters of these tamils now could not even speak in Tamil and they could not even understand what is caste. One day we fill find jharkhand and Bihari labourers ploughing tamil lands. These days are not far off. In those days politics(invasions) created intermixing of races. Now it is economics(globalisation) creates intermixing. You will be surpirsed to know in last three years more than 100 wealthy grooms of dominant caste in namakkal married kerala girls(bride shortage and refusal of the particular caste woman to marry men doing business).
swaminathan
12/03/2012
Article Comment Well ! No doubut about the true saying of the facts which is depicted above, as a victim of Brahmin within Brahminism itself, I lived in Agraharam over 22 years during my yonger days, college, schools days, much about to say the plight of the poor brahmin, who are looked by the same caste people, when the family is down due to kala chakra, they are taken for a ride and worst then a slavery treatment, that is the reason, people get migrates to different parts of the world and settled, as I am staying in Bangalore, and overseas served.
Last but one, it is true that well educated Brahmin girls, perfer only NB's rather than available Brahmin, due to lust and SMS {Sex, Money, Social security), so on......

It is an eye opener topic, debtable one, unless they change their over all attitude, they nevery going to attain the past peak and recognition, and they will be isolated for ever.

Most of the tamil brahmin, preast in the villages or very badly affected and there is no 3 kala pooja in many siva and perumal temple, which I visit very ofter at Thanjur and Trichy during St, Thagarajar Music festival, which I never miss, even today.

Pl post more on the topic to correct themselve and come victories

sathya/bangalore
SATHYANARAYANAN
07/17/2012
Article Comment Though unfortunate, true.

Let us leave these perverts. I have seen lot of Brahmins ( a lot ) helping other brahmins in day to day activities, even in getting a job. We do have softcorner for brahmins. These craps are in limelight and got name because they abused the religion. There are other people too, who at least did not defame brahminism and still popular. Like Balakumaran. Just trying to see the positive side of it.

Looking at the level of common brahmin, they are respected if they adhere brahminism. Otherwise, all the NB get together and tell "I know a brahmin, he eats NV.". It is difficult to get birth as brahmins, now that we have it, why not adhere to the rules. What happiness we get by avoiding the rules,and letting other community guys talk about us.

One thing which nobody can deny: In any office, only brahmins support brahmins. Nobody else. And we will continue doing so.

Ratchet
04/16/2012
Article Comment This is a good article to read and to assimilate the facts, however, bitter it is. Historically Jewish community is persecuted all over Europe and in particular Hitler´s ascension to power in Nazi Germany is a good example of how to identify a common enemy to progress and personal gains. What we see in Tamil Nadu is such formula was extended deliberately to sustain personal gains. These discriminatory patterns indecently applied to gather political, and cinema glitz and glamour in Tamil Nadu. No cure can be found until the basic mentality of ours change to recognize that are only sex distinction (Male and female) and class difference (Rich-poor and middle class. That is nature and rests are all mileage seekers for the personal gains attitude. There are moral slips in every community, and that is human nature to be greed and lust to make use of the situation provided to him or her, why pick and bait only Brahmins because they are hopeless minority in Tamil Nadu. We are all Indians and should be proud of that identity, uniting rather than dividing and fragmenting.
Naithirithi T Chellappa
04/15/2012
Article Comment Fully Agree with Smitha.

A Malayalee will always stand by a malayalee, a telugu will stand by a telugu, a kannadiga will stand by another kannadiga, but barring a few exceptions, there are very few tamil brahmins who will support other brahmins - may be it is the crab mentality or frog mentality of pulling down others - one wonders the reason behind it.

As regards the priests, once greed has taken over them, there is very little scope for devotion. Agree that the priests have to also survive and may need support, but in that process they can't eschew the basic etiquette.
gvenkatesh
04/10/2012
Article Comment The article is a fine one. But tell me 1 trhing - how many brahmins are really brahmins in the true sense of the word?

They consume non vegetarian food, drink & smoke. They lust after women. We came across a case recently of a temple gurukkal taking videos of himself with women devotess right next to the garbhaa graha on his cell phone.

Can anyting be more shameful?

If a brahmin follows the austere ways, non brahmins will look up to him & respect him.

That he has failed to do. The fault lies with him.

As for kamal haasan & others, they are porukis who are best ignored.
smitha
04/09/2012
Article Comment I am not a Tamil Brahmin, belongs to kannada brahmin but whatever detailed above is true and correct. No one brahmin supporting in the office or anywhere
VITTAL
02/16/2012
Article Comment absolutely true. wonderful article.
s.charumathi
09/06/2011
Article Comment You dont have to be in Tamilnadu to be successful. Tamil brahmins
have stood tall and are successful in all parts of the world!
Guru
11/29/2010
Article Comment The answer to the reasons why this occurs is simple.
(1) Consider the case of Sherlock Holmes: Watson observes Holmes using drugs and begs him to stop. Holmes, in effect, replies that he has a tremendously sharp brain which is unable to exist without the world of solving complex criminal cases. Those who have such intelligence(i.e. Brahmins) MUST use it correctly in bhakti, dhyana, yoga, swadhyaya and social service etc, failing which the mind seeks other avenues.
(2) The power of suggestion: The Works of Ambedkar, EVR, their followers and the constant baiting by the ELM leave an indelible mark on most minds exposed to this onslaught. Such people react in peculiar ways: the Stockholm Syndrome in hostages definitely has an echo here.This effect is observable in Maharashtra also.Understand this, move away and move on.
(3) The story of Shiva, Parvati and Nandi is worth repeating here. The Divine couple walk alongside the bull and the public comments about their lack of enterprise in using the bull for transportation. The Couple climb onto the bull and the public talks about overloading the bull, whereupon Parvati dismounts. The public then talks of a strong husband using the bull rather than allowing his delicate wife to do so.Shiva dismounts and Parvati climbs onto the bull's back, whereupon the public talk about the lady not having respect for her husband, who walks behind the bull.. Finally, both Shiva and Parvati dismount and the status quo is restored. YOU ARE DAMNED IF YOU DO AND DAMNED IF YOU DON'T. Follow the ancient ways and disregard ephemeral "public" opinion.
Kamalahasan and family and their bizarre postures and opinions will not matter if you are rooted and act out of your own belief and conviction.
4) Lastly, every individual must have 5 important facts permanently in his/her life: A santh (or spiritual leader), a panth ( or established dharmic path), a mantra (or fomulaic statement), a kanth ( or personal God) and a granth (or established dharmic book).
One reading of the "Bhaja Govindam" will clarify the last point. The towering intellect of our last 3 acharyas is enough to guide us permanently.Hari Om!
seadog4227
09/17/2010
Share This Page
Post a Comment
Bookmark and Share
Name*
Email ID*  (will not be published)
Comment
Verification Code*
M9J49
Please fill the above code for verification.

    

 
 
Top | Society




    A Bystander's Diary     Analysis     Architecture     Astrology     Ayurveda     Book Reviews
    Buddhism     Business     Cartoons     CC++     Cinema     Computing Articles
    Culture     Dances     Education     Environment     Family Matters     Festivals
    Flash     Ghalib's Corner     Going Inner     Health     Hinduism     History
    Humor     Individuality     Internet Security     Java     Linux     Literary Shelf
    Love Letters     Memoirs     Musings     My Word     Networking     Opinion
    Parenting     People     Perspective     Photo Essays     Places     PlainSpeak
    Quotes     Ramblings     Random Thoughts     Recipes     Sikhism     Society
    Spirituality     Stories     Teens     Travelogues     Vastu     Vithika
    Women     Workshop
RSS Feed RSS Feed Home | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Site Map
No part of this Internet site may be reproduced without prior written permission of the copyright holder.
Developed and Programmed by ekant solutions