What went wrong for UDF?

Narrow escape for UDF in Kerala Assembly Elections 2011: 

When counting started on May 13, nobody expected that election in Kerala, one month ago, was such a closely-contested battle. UDF managed to have a narrow escape. Out of 140 seats, they won 72 seats and LDF 68. It is a very thin margin. Not many expect that the UDF government would complete its full term. 

Two years back, people taught LDF a lesson in the Lok-Sabha elections. For the average Kerala voter it was their wish  fulfilled when CPI (M) & partners lost majority of the seats they contested. People gave them a chance to learn and improve.  In the elections to local bodies too, it was a victory for the UDF.  For the communist block it was a big shock as there was a considerable shrinkage in vote share in their  strongholds. In the present elections too, pre poll surveys predicted a comfortable victory for the Congress led UDF. The UDF internal predictions gave them 90 to 95 seats. Congress and UDF camp was confident about a landslide victory. 

Prior to assembly elections, few of the LDF constituents migrated to UDF. Overall impression was that of a surge in public support for the UDF. But unfortunately, popular support that the UDF garnered lasted for a short period.  Many factors contributed to it. More than anything, it was a PR fiasco for the UDF. While LDF used all available communication roots in reaching out to the public, UDF camp literally stunned at the new found belligerent attitude of the leftists. The left front could exploit each and every opportunity to project themselves as the right ruling front for Kerala. This article explores some of the aspects that went against UDF as that contributed in developing a negative image for them in the context of a systematic media & PR campaign by LDF.  

Expansion Hurt UDF Prospects 

UDF expansion literally hurt its prospects rather than helping it in anyway. For the traditional UDF sympathizers there was no beauty in the new alliance equations evolved, as for many, a communal angle was obvious. Kerala Congress merger drama was limited at their leadership level, without the grassroots supporting it. Many perceive Kerala Congress Mani-Joseph merger was an attempt at forming a grant Christian- Catholic electoral alliance with ulterior motives, mainly to emerge as a bargaining bloc in the post poll scenario. Not too many Congress sympathizers took it lightly as well as neutral UDF supporters, who wanted that secular climate prevail and communal equations remain balanced. 

Veerendra Kumar led Socialist Janata faction, which was an LDF constituent earlier was given an entry into the UDF. Has Congress or UDF benefitted from this new ally? Their hard bargaining and extraordinary public postures while seat sharing talks were going on, sent negative signals to UDF and Congress sympathizers. The signal was that the UDF camp is not united, while they are going to face the crucial election. Parties without substantial electoral base and those with very little votes making huge claims during the time of seat allocation and mild success of Congress leadership in managing its alliance partners coupled with the challenge of adhering to extremely unrealistic formulas by Congress high-command to satisfy youth brigade altogether caused poor performance of UDF in Kerala elections.

Poor PR and Media Management 

A close look at the UDF performance, which is indeed a debacle, convinces us that it was in the context  of a poor PR and media management. Whereas, LDF could utilize each and every opportunity in building up a good image over a short period of time. It is not just VS Achuthanandan factor that helped LDF. UDF could not face the onslaught that VS and the LDF camp managed over media and communication channels. UDF was stunned when they faced them. Also, UDF camp was confident and sure about a comfortable victory. So they were callous about their campaign strategy, image building exercises and working out a successful PR & media management plan. LDF could score points on all these. 

A UDF supporter received a phone call from the LDF candidate in a central Travancore constituency requesting for blessings and prayer support. He was convinced that the candidate himself called him up until he heard the same story from many in the constituency, as it was a recorded message. LDF learned to successfully use such modern communication techniques. The same candidate experimented an old strategy that the UDF leaders now discarded, sending postal letters requesting for vote, usually written by volunteers with a stamped signature of the candidate looking original, which seemed to have worked very well for the LDF, in reaching out to neutral votes. 

Overcrowded UDF 

Election results proved the weakness of overcrowded UDF camp. A UDF without Kerala Congress Joseph and Socialist Janata, would have been a much more powerful and cohesive alliance. Socialist Janata was never part of any UDF or Congress and it would be difficult for its cadres to suddenly work with and vote for a Congress candidate. Further, there are strong ideological factors that go against their working together with UDF partners. It is the case with many Joseph group supporters too. For them long term left association made them develop an inclination to the kind of left wing politics and left ideology. This is very much true for Kerala Congress Joseph’s party cadres and supporters at the local level. 

Migration to UDF only at Leadership Level:
Cadres at Grassroots remained with LDF

For the Socialist Janata, long term association or not, they were one of the pillars of anti-congress politics in Kerala as well as in India. There was no strong & convincing justification for Socialist Janata to offer for leaving LDF and their supporters found it difficult to adjust with the new local level coalition realities. When LDF declared their Chief Ministerial candidate as VS Achuthanandan, that made some ripples at the support base of new UDF allies like Socialist Janata and Kerala Congress Joseph group as they now opted to go along with their  old LDF friends at local level. Going along with their old political rivals ( Congress & UDF) locally, was difficult, in the future as well, they were convinced.

Intra-coalition Contradictions in UDF

UDF camp was confident from the very beginning about a clean sweep in the assembly polls. During pre electioneering days and during election days matter that bothered the UDF leaders was post poll government formation, power sharing issues and such other matters. Thus there was a grant merger drama by Kerala Congress. As Kerala Congress Joseph was in  LDF  for almost 30 years, many Congress workers could not come into terms with that merger. It has created intra-coalition contradictions as far as UDF is concerned. Moreover, in many parts of the State, Kerala Congress Joseph group workers remained where they were. It seems that merger worked only at the top level among the leadership, if at all any of the Kerala Congress faction really commands any considerable vote bank, except in Pala or Thodupuzha as this election proved.  

Helicopter Use Affected UDF Image

UDF hired a helicopter for transporting its national leaders when they visit the State during election time between different campaign sites. It was hired for a month or so. LDF alleged that the money with which the helicopter was hired comes from 2G scam and other similar scandals like Commonwealth games etc.  On one or two occasions, KPCC President used the helicopter for travelling locally between Harippad and Kottayam etc. Others as well might have used the helicopter.  A congress worker whom I met said ‘this extravaganza was not needed.  We found it difficult to justify such things.’ 

Endosulfan and Prof. KV Thomas 

Many of the attempts to malign UDF image could not find much success, for instance, attempt to resurrect Ice cream parlor case. But such extravaganza ( Helicopter hiring) by the Congress leaders had a negative impact on the UDF. Similarly, LDF could create an impression that UDF and UPA is in favor of Endosulfan.  LDF got a friend in Prof. K. V Thomas as early as October 2010, when his statement regarding endosulfan on October 26, 2010 in Kasargod that “None of the studies conducted by the Kerala and central governments have conclusively proved through scientific tests and analysis that endosulfan had caused these diseases and deaths. Many other states in India and also foreign countries, where this insecticide-cum-acaricide is being made use of, have not reported such ill affects.”   Though later on he apologized for the statement,  it had already done the damage as it was agood weapon against the Congress, UDF and the Central government. This  was extensively used to portray congress’s apathy in matters of public health. 

During the electioneering there was a media awareness campaign that went on throughout both in visual and print media regarding Endosulfan. Though it was A K Antony government that banned endosulfan in Kerala, awareness campaign about the dangerous of endosulfan and demands for a national level ban during electioneering that went on in the media side by side went against UDF interests. 

Corruption and Congress

In addition to that there were issues related to corruption. Though there were leaders from LDF also involved in corruption, VS Achuthanandan was very successful in projecting UDF as a formation of corrupt leaders. Judgements in cases involving Balakrishna Pillai also came and it was timely for the LDF. Corruption was another matter. 2G scam and commonwealth corruption deals involving senior congress men also negatively impacted congress image. Many people here equated inaction of Prime Minister in 2G spectrum as corruption. While Congress at the Center sent out a message of inaction and their soft stand on corruption, in Kerala VS Achuthanandan gave out an impression to the public that he is the only hope when it comes to fighting corruption. 

Inflation and Cochin Metro Project Delay 

Prices of essential commodities were all rising. Already several times petroleum prices went up at a frequency of 15 to 20 days. Family budgets went for a tussle. All sections of society, were at the receiving end , may be except Ministers, MPs,MLAs, bureaucrats and the rich class. Voters were waiting for an opportunity to send a message to the party or formation responsible for price rise. Onion prices sky-rocketed but actions to curtail it came very late after middlemen achieving their goals. For a watchful electorate as that of Kerala, this was more than enough to vote against the state level partners of UPA. Similarly, when sanctioning of Cochin Metro Rail project, statement by Planning Commission deputy chief Montek Singh’s statement that Cochin metro as a non-feasible project brought out confusions and contradictions in the matter of policies with regard to public transport. On the one hand there is de-controlled pricing policy in petroleum sector causing prices going up making the life of all sections difficult and on the other hand planning commission chief of India making a comment that he won’t favor creation of cheaper public transport infrastructure investment. Everything together gave an impression that, UPA government as anti-poor and anti-people and they are there for protecting the interests of corporates. Most of the traditional congress supporters whom I spoke were all too much disgusted with price rise, petroleum pricing scenario, UPA – planning commission stand on Cochin metro and such other matters. 

Congress’s Organizational weaknesses 

Other aspects that went against the Congress is its organizational weakness and over confidence. Congress and UDF were overconfident from the very beginning and they were so sure of a victory, says, CK Vishwanath a political observer.  District Congress Committees ( DCCs )in most districts are ineffective. Organizational positions are held by cronies of senior leaders. How many of them have got real organizational skills, grass-roots support base need to be looked into. 

Import of candidates is always something that the local leaders always used to resist. Unfortunately, imported candidates could not get assimilated well this time and UDF had to pay the price.  Though people aspired for a change in Kerala, voters and even UDF supporters were irritated over such many things. Congress leaders and PCC leadership should understand that the time of recommendations and connections being a factor in selecting party candidates as well as organizational office bearers has to be ended. Central leadership and youth brigade should understand that winning election is not a child’s play in Kerala. Fixing quotas for youth or any other particular section won’t do any good when it comes to winning a major electoral battle. Candidates win-ability should have been the major factor in selecting party candidates. Also, time has come for Congress leadership to incorporate people from local levels at the party leadership.  Their upward growth in the party hierarchy should also be ensured. There should be more transparency in organizational matters especially in selection of party office bearers and candidates.   

VS Achuthanandan as the Moral Crusader 

Achuthanandan’s comeback as the Chief Ministerial candidate also helped LDF gain support from civil society and community based organizations.  Achuthanandan could emerge as a moral crusader of Kerala society says Vishwanath,.  He could really speak what people felt regarding corruption, inflation and other pertinent  issues. UDF lacked such a leader, says Vishwanath and .. ‘when VM Sudheeran declined to contest the election, UDF lost a leader who could counter Achuthanandan’s moral crusader image’. Achuthanandan could also raise some hopes in the developmental front when stand-still with regard to  smart city project in Koch could be ended.

Communal Political Strategy of UDF Partners 

2011 election also proved that the communal vote base of Kerala Congress (M) was too shallow and they have no committed vote bank. It is a well known practice of Kerala Congress factions to count all Christian votes as their committed vote bank and bargain for seats wherever there are few Christian population. In Tiruvalla, a constituency considered to be a Kerala Congress Mani stronghold was proved to be wrong. Throughout all the wards in that constituency, LDF gained considerable lead, proving that communal political strategy can boomerang. Here LDF defeated Kerala Congress ( Mani) candidate by more than 10,000 votes. Kerala Congress Mani, in a coalition context, bargain for their seats and continuously win elections. It is an interesting phenomenon. Mr. K M Mani and his party may not have any obvious communal objective but their political strategy is communal and that encouraged communalism in Kerala politics. In fact such political practices have deeply divided Kerala society on communal lines.  

To Conclude, it was the image building exercise done successfully in the last three months prior to the polling by LDF led by VS Achuthanandan made the elections such a closely fought battle. BJP could gain more votes. Congress’s overconfidence and their failure to counter PR and media onslaught by LDF was also a major factor along with the moral crusader image of VS Achuthanandan and that helped neutralize anti-incumbency factor very much. Though UDF could regain power, it would be difficult for the front managers to play the coalition politics as earlier in such an overcrowded coalition.   


More by :  Dr. P Koshy

Top | Analysis

Views: 3450      Comments: 6

Comment In sight ful analysis by Dr Koshi, and sadly reading the comments of some of the comments, I feel that the BJP/RSS are a threat to India and Kerala as a whole. On reading the comment by Jai Kumar he was ranting on the fact that a good number of candidates were from minority communities. I will remind the dear fellow that candidates aren't elected on the basis of their religion ( maybe they are in some cases ) but it is not the rule especially when it comes to the more moral LDF. Miniorities have been stigmatised in states like Gujarat and the chief minister is considered a national hero by the likes of Jai Kumar whereas in reality there cannot be a doubt that Narendra Modi is a criminal who deserves to be behind bars. Statements like Kerala is going the Kashmir way reflects a certain thinking in the BJP/RSS supporter, to divide the society and ruin the state. The BJP/RSS has ruined the atmosphere in Gujarat, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradhesh, Chattisgharh. All this proves is that BJP/RSS are a threat to India and need to be banned. BJP members need to be stripped of Indian nationality if they are found guilty of inciting riots for their own political gain. They should not be allowed to open bank accounts, their children should not be given admission in any school and their businesses boycotted. That will cut off the supply of funds to this cancer.

Jagan Radhakrishnan
18-Feb-2012 06:12 AM

Comment Your evaluation is correct and the point that overconfidensce of UDF was the reason of its poor perfomence is a warning its future perfomence.

Rev Dr Sabu Philip
09-Jun-2011 08:34 AM

The article was well written and gave indepth analysis of the recent election results in kerala.

If the UDF is in power today, it is due to minority votes. Their performance was mediocre considering their good performance in the last Lok Sabha election and Panchayat Election.

Mr. Rahul Gandhi's attack on Mr.V.S Achuthanandan's age, angered many senior citizens, and they expressed their displeasure by voting against UDF.

The current government of Mr.Oomen Chandy, will be severely tested on all fronts as the alliance partners will be exerting pressure to benefit their group.

Koshy george
03-Jun-2011 12:04 PM

It is unfotunate for the Kerala society and polity that the Indian national congress with a great history of sucular credence and working for communal hrmony before independence has to bow down at the door steps of the 'Thangal mansions', bishop 'palaces' and Nair samathis to win an election.. However, it is heartening that the herds are slowly but gradually distancing themselves from the 'fatwas'. Koshy was successful to unravel most of the campaign issues connected with recent Kerala Assembly election. However the UDF's attempt to cling on to the feudal caste-communal-religious oscurantists by tying up with the neo-liberal aspirations are not given adequate prominence.

I am glad to note that Dr. Perumal Koshy is emerging as an outstanding political analyst and I wish him all the best.

Jose George

Jose George
03-Jun-2011 10:15 AM

Comment Whatever be the political, electoral and sociological analysis that one can make, the FACT remains that UDF essentially represents only the Muslim and Christian interests of Kerala. Though still 55% Hindu on paper, Kerala under UDF rule will be ruled by the two arch COMMUNAL parties - Indian Union Muslim League(IUML) and Kerala Congress (KC) led by the highly controversial Kunhali Kutty and KM Maani respectively. The so-called UDF leader Oommen Chandy will have very limited role. 75% of the UDF MLAs are from the Minority(?) communities and what is going to happen is only obvious.

Kerala is heading the Kashmir way. The large presence of Gulf Keralites and the entry of modern East India Companies like DP World and TECOM (Arab companies) will accelerate the process further. It is time for Kerala Pandits to get ready for their flight and plight.

03-Jun-2011 02:46 AM

Comment The article gives a very good analysis of the recent election scenario in Kerala. It is right that there is too much of internal fight going on. But the assumption that the Kerala Congress Mani Group is communal in its election strategy is not correct. The communal divide, to my opinion, was initiated and is being propagated and sustained by the LDF for its own political gain. Sometimes LDF gives the impression that it wants to create an anti-Christian lobby in the state. I thought the merger with Joseph group would give a positive push- namely the Kerala Congress or Congress party as such assimilates the virtues of socialism to some extent. That would do good to the Congress. But ofcourse for that one has to get to the grass root level and create awareness in the people than flying by helicopters!!

The Merging of Socialist JD, I feel was a wrong strategy..
Such mergings take place very often out of pure self interest and political power calculations. UDF should have tested the loyalty and sincerety before doing so.

That is very true: UDF is poor as far as PR and Media methods are concerned. It is high time that one learns to make use of it, as we live in a Media dictated world.

I think yet the greatest illusion was the idea that UDF nurtured: victory is their's in every alternative election i.e. if five years LDF rule then the next five years UDF. It is high time that UDF wakes up from the slumber and its dream of such automatic power change!! Now UDF should prove itself through good governance and actions effecting the welfare of the people at all levels of social strata and in particular of the poor. Besides UDF should pay much attention to environmental problems, like removal of garbage, giving; showing new perspectives to develop agriculture, promote job and environment-friendly industries, effective health and old people care etc...In short a tinge of red and green shade would do good to the UDF and Kerala !!
Thank you Koshi for the insightful analysis of the Election in Kerala

Anu Menon
02-Jun-2011 10:36 AM

Name *

Email ID

Comment *
Verification Code*

Can't read? Reload

Please fill the above code for verification.