Rescuing the Lokpal Bill by Rajinder Puri SignUp

In Focus

Photo Essays


Random Thoughts

Our Heritage


Society & Lifestyle


Creative Writings

Book Reviews
Literary Shelf
Analysis Share This Page
Rescuing the Lokpal Bill
by Dr. Rajinder Puri Bookmark and Share

Delhi Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit in response to the questionnaire sent by the Union government to chief ministers seeking their views on the Lokpal Bill has suggested that the Bill should be scrapped because the existing institutions are adequate to deal with corruption. I too have been advocating this. However this may not be politically practical.

In public perception the Lokpal Bill has become identified with the resolve to end corruption.

All political parties have supported the creation of a Lokpal. It is an ancient proposal. In India old is gold. The ability to think independently is sadly absent. Mismanagement and confused thinking led the government to dig itself into a hole. Its decision to call an all party meeting to discuss the issue is unlikely to help. Opposition parties will seek to embarrass the government which will compound confusion and not help resolve the issue. But neither the government nor most opposition parties can altogether abandon the Lokpal Bill without loss of public face. 

However, there is a way out.

The Lokpal Bill can be rescued without upsetting the existing constitutional structure as the government wants, and at the same time effectively addressing popular demands voiced by representatives of the civil society.

The following steps need to be taken to satisfy the concerns of both sides.

In order to differentiate the role of the Lokpal from that of the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) the new institution should be entrusted with dealing only with political corruption that involves ministers, chief ministers and the prime minister. The CVC may continue to deal with the rest of the corruption cases. The judiciary should be dealt with by an independent Judicial Reforms Commission that may along with the Lokpal be made a constitutional body. Apart from corruption there could be other aspects of judicial functioning that may need attention demanding specialized legal knowledge.

All these constitutional bodies should be under the direct purview of the President. The CBI too should be made into a constitutional body directly accountable to the President. It has been suggested that the Lokpal should consist of eleven members. All the members of the proposed Lokpal would be appointed by the President without clearance by the cabinet. It might be recalled that in disputes between the Election Commission, which is also a constitutional body, and the cabinet, there is already experience from during the tenure of Mr. TN Seshan indicating that the President has to act as impartial arbiter. In the new dispensation the President may continue playing the role of adviser to the cabinet and to parliament without exercising final authority. But with regard to the functioning of all constitutional bodies the President would exercise direct authority over them. This should be explicitly stated for the public satisfaction. This arrangement would be in total conformity with the existing Constitution without disturbing the existing political structure. 

It may also be desirable that no anonymous complaints may be considered by the proposed Lokpal. All complainants would have to identify themselves and furnish credible prima facie evidence. It may also be preferable that the Lokpal should not suo moto launch investigation or prosecution unless formal complaints are received. If such an arrangement were made it would call for a presidential role that was not required in the past. The electorate would have to take note of this change. Therefore if such a Bill is successfully drafted it should come into operation only after President Pratibha Patil’s term ends and a new President is elected. If this suggested course to create a new Lokpal post is adopted it would satisfactorily address the concerns voiced by the government and the representatives of civil society. It would be a decisive step forward in restoring democratic governance in accordance with the Constitution, and effectively address corruption.  

Share This:
More by :  Dr. Rajinder Puri
Top | Analysis
Views: 1862      Comments: 3

Comments on this Article

Comment Shyam and Ashish, I appreciate your anger but not your reasoning. How do you guarantee that the all powerful Lokpal you envisage will not be as bad as the present ministers? Even the President under the present Constitution can be removed through impeachment. Who will remove the Jan Lokpal? How will he be removed? Anger is not the best path to wisdom.

My Word
07/06/2011 19:10 PM

Comment yes i totally concur with shyam.It wont be a success until unless we create a totally independent Body with all the powers without any intervention of neither President nor the bloody,murky ministers and it must be transparent into the bargain so that public have full congnizence of its deeds.

Ashish Thakur
07/06/2011 19:10 PM

The proposed Lokpal Bill will not do a thing without a prosecuting body. The present set up namely, CBI with its history can not function effectively. There must be a total overhaull of our constitution creating a powerful Investigating & Prosecuting bodies with full powers. Any President or Home Minister wants interfere with the investigation, there must be a written direction not merely a phone call. Every thing must be on record. Then only it might work. .Look at the history our CBI ! Is there any scandal successfully concluded any time? Why people think that a new Lokpal Bill will work? If you create an Investigating & Prosecuting body with full powers, without the interference by the President or Ministers, It makes sense.

Shyam R. Shetty
07/05/2011 19:10 PM

Name *
Email ID
 (will not be published)
Comment *
Verification Code*
Can't read? Reload
Please fill the above code for verification.
1999-2022 All Rights Reserved
No part of this Internet site may be reproduced without prior written permission of the copyright holder