Society & Lifestyle
|Analysis||Share This Page|
The President’s First Test!
|by Dr. Rajinder Puri|
President Pranab Mukherjee can forget any visions he might have entertained about leading a relaxed and laid back life in Rashtrapati Bhawan. In the very first day of his presidency he is confronted by a crisis that calls for his immediate round-the-clock attention. Assuming of course that he is serious about discharging his duties as outlined in the Constitution which he is sworn to defend. Indeed, the manner in which the President will deal with the immediate crisis could set the tone of his tenure. This crisis will test his credentials for impartiality and for awareness about his responsibilities. The crisis of course relates to the current events in Assam.
The President can act conventionally as a virtual spectator while the Union Cabinet takes key decisions. That was how former President Kalam dealt with the crisis in Bihar. President Kalam did something he should not have at the bidding of the cabinet by dissolving the state assembly. He earned a permanent black mark from the Supreme Court which considered the decision unconstitutional and in its ruling even obliquely criticized the President. The SC stated that no objective material had been placed before the President as required by law to justify his signing of the Proclamation to dissolve the Bihar assembly. The court went on to warn the President that he was not immune from the court’s scrutiny. Such criticism of a President by the Supreme Court was unprecedented. President Kalam acted in relation to Bihar when he should not have. Now will President Mukherjee not act in relation to Assam when he should act? To determine that one must first appreciate the situation in Assam.
There is a history of ethnic tension and violence in Assam between Bodo tribals and Muslim Bangladeshi migrants who infiltrated the state decades earlier. After a recent period of peace violence suddenly flared following unexplained murders that led to mutual recrimination and violence between both communities. The Bodos are aggrieved because Muslim bodies have traditionally opposed the formation of a Bodoland state. The death toll stands at 40. More important, close to 200,000 villagers had to flee and are lodged in 42 relief camps. Their homes have been set on fire.
Instead Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh perfunctorily instructed the Assam Chief Minister Mr. Tarun Gogoi to act against the ring leaders. The CM accepted responsibility for the break down of law and order but did not resign. He told media: "Do you think I should run away? I am a general fighting in a war. I will be the last one to resign. If I have to resign I will do it subsequently, not now."
For a start he should enquire from the government whether the Assam Governor had submitted any report on the recent events. If not, the President should summon Assam Governor Mr. Janaki Ballav Patnaik and ask him why a report has not been presented. The functioning of the Governor is the direct responsibility of the President.
The current violence can seriously jeopardize the rapidly improving relations between India and Bangladesh. It goes without saying that there are hostile foreign elements that have a powerful vested interest in preventing that to happen. The Ministry of Home Affairs has ruled out a foreign hand in the recent violence. Home Secretary Mr. RK Singh said: “We have told the state government to book the ring leaders of both sides immediately.”
To be forewarned is to be forearmed. As the Supreme Commander of the armed forces the President might also summon the Army Chief for a quiet discussion. In the event of worsening conditions what could be the prospects? After considering all possibilities have the armed forces made contingency plans related to the crisis? All these measures of course call for a sustained approach by the President over a period of time. What is immediately relevant is that Governor’s rule is imposed in Assam and an effective administration to safeguard security and revive law and order is installed.
|More by : Dr. Rajinder Puri|
|Views: 1155 Comments: 3|
Comments on this Article
07/29/2012 10:38 AM
07/27/2012 08:04 AM
07/26/2012 13:28 PM
|Top | Analysis|