Blog

Beyond Caste and Creed

India’s greatest civilisational strength lies in its diversity. People belonging to different religions, castes, linguistic groups and cultural traditions have coexisted for centuries, enriching the country’s pluralistic identity. Yet, ironically, this very diversity is increasingly being turned into an instrument of political mobilisation, social dominance and communal polarisation. A society that ought to recognise every individual as a human being is becoming increasingly preoccupied with questions of caste, religion, food habits, worship and cultural identity. The steady intensification of these tendencies over the past twelve years poses a serious challenge to constitutional democracy and the idea of an inclusive India.

Caste and religion should remain matters of personal identity, belief and social background. Neither can be a legitimate measure of an individual's worth, dignity or character. Unfortunately, the exploitation of caste loyalties and religious sentiments for political advantage, coupled with the deliberate cultivation of suspicion and hostility between communities, has acquired alarming proportions. This phenomenon must be examined not merely through the prism of electoral politics but also in the context of families, educational institutions, social organisations and the Indian diaspora.

The Politics of Division
 
The Constitution of independent India abolished untouchability, guaranteed equality before the law and sought to establish a society founded on justice and fraternity. Nevertheless, caste hierarchies and religious prejudices have continued to influence social relations. Over the past twelve years, caste calculations and religious identities have assumed an increasingly prominent place in electoral politics. Instead of addressing unemployment, education, healthcare, inflation and economic inequality, political discourse is frequently diverted towards temples, mosques, religious practices, food choices and community identities.

This tendency is not confined to any single political party. Across States, different political formations have cultivated caste associations, religious organisations and community leaders to consolidate electoral constituencies. Social groups are often treated as vote banks rather than citizens entitled to equal rights and opportunities. Political power is pursued through the mobilisation of inherited identities, while the larger responsibility of fostering social harmony is frequently neglected.

An independent report by the Centre for the Study of Organised Hate recorded 1,165 instances of hate speech in 2024, including 462 attributed to political leaders. Although these are not official government statistics, they illustrate the disturbing extent to which divisive rhetoric has entered political discourse. Political leadership in a democracy must unite society, not fragment it for electoral gain.

Violence in the Name of Identity
 
The past twelve years have witnessed several deeply disturbing incidents of caste- and religion-based violence. The lynching of Mohammad Akhlaq in Dadri in 2015, the assault on Pehlu Khan in Rajasthan in 2017, attacks on Dalits in Gujarat, the communal violence in Delhi in 2020 and the ethnic conflict in Manipur from 2023 onwards expose the destructive consequences of hatred and polarisation.

The violence in Manipur, involving the Meitei and Kuki communities, resulted in hundreds of deaths, widespread displacement, destruction of homes and property, and horrific violence against women. It remains a grim reminder of the consequences of allowing ethnic and religious divisions to overwhelm constitutional governance.

Caste-based atrocities are equally disturbing. According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), 57,789 crimes against Scheduled Castes and 12,960 crimes against Scheduled Tribes were registered in 2023. The corresponding figures for 2024 were 55,698 and 9,966 respectively. A marginal decline in reported cases cannot be mistaken for the disappearance of discrimination. These figures represent only registered offences; the actual magnitude of the problem may be considerably greater because many victims remain reluctant or unable to approach the police.

Mob violence in the name of cow protection, attacks on people over their dietary preferences, discrimination against individuals belonging to particular religious communities and calls for economic boycotts have further weakened social trust. Such practices strike at the very foundations of individual liberty and equal citizenship.

Bulldozer Justice and the Erosion of the Rule of Law

The growing practice in certain States of demolishing the homes and commercial establishments of people accused of crimes has raised serious constitutional concerns. There is a fundamental distinction between removing an illegal structure through lawful procedure and demolishing someone's property as a form of punishment merely because an allegation has been made against them.

The authority to determine guilt belongs to the judiciary, not to the executive. In November 2024, the Supreme Court laid down important safeguards against arbitrary demolitions, emphasising the necessity of due process, prior notice and an opportunity to be heard. It also made clear that the properties of family members cannot be demolished merely because one individual is accused of an offence.

The rule of law cannot accommodate collective punishment or executive vengeance. A bulldozer cannot become an instrument of justice, nor can administrative power substitute for judicial procedure. Constitutional governance demands accountability, fairness and respect for the rights of every citizen, irrespective of religious or political identity.

When Love Becomes a Crime
 
One of the most disturbing manifestations of caste and religious prejudice is the resistance to marriages across caste and religious boundaries. Two consenting adults who choose to spend their lives together are frequently confronted with threats, intimidation, social ostracism and even murder. The so-called honour of families and communities is invoked to justify the destruction of individual freedom.

The murder of Pranay in Telangana in 2018, following his inter-caste marriage to Amrutha, exposed the brutality of caste supremacy. The killing of Gokulraj in Tamil Nadu and several other instances of honour-based violence demonstrate how deeply entrenched caste prejudices can become. Young couples are forced to abandon their homes, live under police protection or endure relentless harassment. In some cases, unbearable social pressure drives them to suicide.

Interfaith marriages have also become increasingly controversial. Relationships between consenting adults are sometimes portrayed as conspiracies involving religious conversion, inviting intimidation and interference by families, social organisations and political groups. Such conduct undermines the autonomy of individuals and their constitutional right to choose their partners.

In the Shakti Vahini case of 2018, the Supreme Court affirmed that consenting adults have the freedom to marry according to their choice and that so-called honour cannot justify interference or violence. Family honour must be measured by the respect shown to individual freedom, not by the ability to control the lives of children.

Caste Travels Beyond India's Borders
 
It is particularly unfortunate that caste prejudices are not always left behind when Indians migrate abroad for education, employment and business. Countries such as the United States, Britain, Canada and Australia have become home to substantial Indian communities. While many Indians contribute enormously to their adopted societies, some have also carried caste-based divisions and discriminatory practices into their overseas social networks.

Caste associations and community organisations have emerged in several countries, sometimes reinforcing social exclusivity in friendships, marriages and professional relationships. The debate over caste discrimination has consequently acquired an international dimension.

In February 2023, Seattle became the first American city to explicitly prohibit caste discrimination through a municipal ordinance. California's proposed Senate Bill 403, which sought to include caste as a protected category under the State's anti-discrimination framework, also generated considerable debate. Although Governor Gavin Newsom vetoed the Bill, he maintained that existing laws already provided protection against caste discrimination.

These developments should prompt serious introspection. Indians who take pride in their country's ancient civilisation and democratic traditions must recognise that exporting caste prejudices undermines India's international reputation and contradicts the universal values of equality and human dignity.

Textbooks and the Politics of Cultural Identity
 
Education is among the most powerful instruments for shaping the outlook of future generations. School textbooks must cultivate scientific temper, critical thinking, constitutional morality, equality and respect for diversity. Yet, changes introduced in the name of cultural preservation, syllabus rationalisation and historical reinterpretation have generated concerns about ideological influence over education.

The rationalisation of NCERT textbooks in 2023 led to the removal or reduction of several portions relating to Mughal history, the Delhi Sultanate, the 2002 Gujarat riots, caste and social movements. While reducing academic burden is a legitimate objective, removing uncomfortable historical realities is not an appropriate educational solution.

History must be taught through evidence, scholarly research and multiple perspectives. No religion should be glorified at the expense of another, and no caste hierarchy should be presented as an unquestionable cultural tradition. Nor should mythology and unverified beliefs displace scientific inquiry.

Children must be encouraged to question, investigate and distinguish historical evidence from ideological interpretation. Textbooks should present India's composite heritage, including the contributions of marginalised communities, reformers, women, religious minorities and social movements. Education must liberate young minds from prejudice rather than reproduce inherited divisions.

The Transformation Must Begin at Home
 
It is convenient to blame political leaders for the spread of casteism and communal hatred. However, society cannot evade its own responsibility. The first lessons in discrimination are often imparted within families. Children who repeatedly hear derogatory remarks about other castes or religions, are discouraged from befriending people from different communities, or are taught to judge others by their birth gradually internalise these prejudices.

Parents must therefore recognise that the values children absorb at home are often more influential than the lessons they learn in classrooms. They must encourage friendships across caste and religious boundaries, respect inter-caste and interfaith marriages, and teach their children that every individual deserves dignity. Family honour lies not in controlling the choices of young adults but in supporting their happiness and freedom.

A Roadmap Towards Social Harmony 

The eradication of caste and religious discrimination requires a coordinated effort by governments, political parties, educational institutions, the media, religious leaders and civil society.

  • First, constitutional values, social justice, human rights and scientific temper must become integral to school education. History textbooks should reflect the contributions of all communities without ideological distortion.
     
  • Second, political parties must be held accountable for speeches and campaigns that incite hatred. The Election Commission must act impartially against divisive electoral practices, irrespective of the political affiliation of those responsible.

  • Third, law enforcement agencies must investigate caste atrocities, mob lynchings, honour killings, communal violence and social boycotts without bias. Victims must receive timely justice, legal assistance, protection and rehabilitation. Every demolition and administrative action must strictly follow the law.

  • Fourth, consenting inter-caste and interfaith couples must be provided adequate protection, access to legal assistance and support in securing housing and livelihoods. The Special Marriage Act should be implemented in a manner that protects privacy and does not expose couples to unnecessary intimidation.

  • Fifth, media organisations and social media platforms must act responsibly against misinformation, fabricated videos and inflammatory content. Citizens, too, must develop the habit of verifying information before sharing it.
     
  • Finally, community organisations should promote collective meals, cultural programmes, educational initiatives and public-service activities involving people from different castes and religions. Religious leaders must emphasise compassion, peace, equality and service to humanity rather than encourage exclusion and hostility.

Humanity Is the True Measure of Indian Identity

India is neither the exclusive possession of one religion nor the inheritance of a single caste or linguistic community. Its civilisation has been enriched by the compassion of Buddhism, the principle of non-violence in Jainism, the humanism of Sufi traditions, the egalitarian spirit of the Bhakti movements, the teachings of Guru Nanak, the commitment to social justice of B.R. Ambedkar and the philosophy of non-violence articulated by Mahatma Gandhi. These diverse traditions form an integral part of India's shared heritage.

The Preamble to the Constitution promises justice, liberty, equality and fraternity. These principles must not remain ornamental expressions in a constitutional document; they must find meaningful expression in everyday life.

Caste may be an inherited social identity and religion a matter of personal faith, but neither can determine a person's worth. Human dignity, compassion, integrity and conduct are the true measures of an individual.

We must ensure that caste discrimination has no place in our homes, religious hatred no place in our neighbourhoods, prejudice no place in our classrooms and divisiveness no place in our politics. Let us bequeath humanity, not caste pride, to future generations. Let religion become a source of compassion rather than an instrument of hatred.

A society that respects every individual as a human being, irrespective of caste, creed or community, is the India that the Constitution envisioned. That alone is the true meaning of Indian civilisation, the enduring strength of our democracy and the finest legacy we can leave to generations yet unborn.

More By  :  Prof. Dr. K. Ram Kishore

  • Views: 20
  • Comments: 0


(will not be published)
1500 characters left
Can't read? Reload
Please fill the above code for verification.