Sep 24, 2023
Sep 24, 2023
A few days ago, the newspapers carried statements of SEBI and private banks’ head honchos declaim against RBI rate cut in absence of other government handouts. What, one wonders, was the purpose of private banks if they can operate only with government handouts? What happens to their much lauded ‘private’ status then?
Banks, entrepreneurs, economic intellectuals’ et al rail against the food bill that promises food in the belly of India’s poor. Instead of those lakhs, they argue in favor of diverting that money to industrialists’ coffers, purportedly to speed up development via industrial growth, claiming that will raise India up faster.
The Question is: against a handout of ‘x’ lakh crores, what guarantee is there of creation of at least ‘y’ thousand jobs? In recent times, the import of state of art technology means less than ‘z’ hundred jobs, generally limited to the upper middle and upper classes?
What are these chaps afraid of? Actually!
Of those lakhs of really poor, who cannot afford one square meal a day, slum dwellers in the smaller towns, rural and tribal areas, the SC and ST deprived classes, who would for the first time get access to food to fill their bellies ….
That, after a full belly, they may want more – amenities, education, health, jobs and some of those goodies, shampoos, Bournvita, chocolates, Maggi, drinks, eats and homes that these gentlemen proclaim to have done wonders in.
Perhaps they know that they will not be able to move fast enough to meet the stepped up demand and then the MNCs will step in while they watch the outcome of their playing ducks and drakes with national investments.
Just as we have watched Sahara and other chit funds fool people of savings; a Mallya lead the high life while his Kingfisher employees make do without salaries, the argument being that Kingfisher Airlines has nothing in common with money spinning breweries, except the common owner? Or all those netas with multiple lakh crores! Has anyone wondered how despite a recession and deflated industrial growth, the personal incomes of big wigs show healthy hikes?
The arguments for industrial growth are well measured:
One industrialist argues, “where do you decide to what level growth should fall? And how do you bring it up? We’ve brought down growth but to what level have we succeeded in controlling inflation?”
The SEBI chairman wanted post office rates and statutory liquid ratios to come down first. CEO, HDFC wanted liquidity to improve with government spending and FII inflows before his bank could do anything. Citibank CEO wanted more government, public and private sector spending to happen with improved liquidity first. And CEO, ICICI bank said that deposit rates would not come down unless the deposit growth rates and seasonal demand improves.
On literacy versus skill development, it is argued that instead of wailing over the ‘missing women’ lost in female feticide, better growth will improve lives of those living children. Why not, but only if factories will sprout that will offer fruitful employment to the boys; allowed to be born and pampered into rapisthood.
In short: Faster industrial growth vs. food in the belly of the starved or semi starved – but only if the government will bankroll that industrial growth!!
Another way out may be if all these industrialists with begging bowls were to check their accounts to see how much they owe the government under what heads and how many petitions and appeals they have filed to stave off that payment. Instead of a vast legal department to deal with those, let them just cough up the balance, to give the government more than enough to either feed those poor or help the new industrial growth along, perhaps both.
Even so, where are all those jobs going to come from? Everyone worth his salt is united in declaring that the government has to get out of the public sector as soon as possible. So one huge employment segment is firmly out!
The private sector creates limited jobs, a couple thousand per hundred crores investment, may be.
That leaves us with faujis, policewallas, babus and netas.
Our army is desperately short of men; their pay is abysmal. But the babus fight any pay hike tooth and nail. Ditto the policewallas for whom the absence of decent pay hike, plus babu-neta demands means more rampant corruption. So unless we really pay our uniformed forces right, another huge segment of employment is closed.
And of course, there is no rein on the recruitment and corruption of the babus and the netas.
Reports from China indicate that their single child policy has now resulted in spoilt brats called Little Emperors, whose self-absorption has led to a damaging decline of the work ethic and discipline that fuelled the country’s dramatic rise. The effects of this phenomena are slated to be felt as soon as 2020 when India’s average age will be 29 against China’s 37, leaving that many less working years left for the working population that in China, struggles with their little emperors, themselves and two sets of retired parents each from the pre-retirement planning days.
Statistics indicate that by 2040 the Indian population will be more than China’s and younger too; that translates into greater productivity – if there are jobs to be productive in. Stats do tell lies, but there is always a grain of truth somewhere. Question is how to we capitalize on this hare and tortoise race with China and feed, house, clothe, education and train our young people to contribute to positive change, not merely terror and rape statistics.
The issue then is of creating jobs. If these biggies want to create jobs, they need gargantuan government handouts which could empty the banks, plus speedy land reforms and acquisitions which will barely give jobs to those dispossessed, plus speedy clearances and infrastructure support - not that their record for giving results despite such support is anything to talk about.
Yet is it possible politically? Even with an election looming? Will the opposition allow that?
What then happens to those teeming hungry millions and their daily bread, while our BMWallahs laugh all the way to those banks?
More by : Kusum Choppra
Food bill has more cons than pros.
And going by the track record of this UPA govt, one hardly expect any genuine resons behind the move. (food for thought - this bill was introduced in 2011).
You rightly pointed out that the large growing population has potential to deliver work but remains untapped. You rightly pointed out that privatization is not an answer to tap this potential. In fact, blind privitazation iteself is harmful to social interests in long term. Instead, public sector industries can be immuned from rampant political interference in order to trun them into profitable business while they cater to welfare of their employees which private industries does not want to do for their employees (for example job security, long term benefits, health benefits, controlling working hours, unnecessary work stress, unnecessary and worthless compitition between employees and so on.)
It is the government who need totake steps and ensure that all sections of sociaety get their basic needs fulfilled to survive and contribute to overall growth.
But, can we expect anything meaningful in national interest from this government at all ?
You wrote of the low pay levels of the Army Officer.Below is given the pay scales of the Officers.This does not include grade pay (Rs.5600 pm),military service pay(Rs.6000 pm) Kit maintainence (Rs.400) Transport allowance, free ration.subsidised accommodation,CSD, 2 months leave +furlough and many other benefits like 50% train/rail concession etc.I think this should be enough for decent living. The civil service Officers do get the same scales.And yes all Police Officers are not corrupt and all civil service officers do not prize postings always.
And any one joins Defence services at his own free will.
Yes, I agree that the poor hardly get any chance to come up.But this is situation in any other country including the USA where I live.
Grade Pay Grade Pay Military Service Pay
Lieutenant 15,600 – 39,100 5,400 6,000
Captain 15,600 – 39,100 5,700 6,000
Major 15,600 – 39,100 5,700 6,000
Lt. Col. 15,600 – 39,100 5,700 6,000
Col. 15,600 – 39,100 5,700 6,000
Brig. 15,600 – 39,100 5,700 6,000
Maj. Gen. 39,200 – 67,000 9,000 Nil
Let. Gen./equ 39,200 – 67,000 11,000 Nil
Vice Chiefs 80,000 Nil Nil
Service Chiefs 90,000 Nil Nil