If I say One, It is not

Ek Kahun To Hai Nahin,
Do Kahun To Gaari.
Hai Jaisa Taisa Rahe,
Kahe Kabir Bichari.

Translation

If I say one, It is not
If I say two, it will be a violation
Let It be what It is
says Kabir upon contemplation

My Understanding

Kabir addresses a fundamental question with remarkable simplicity: Is Existence One, or is it many?

Oneness recognizes Existence as an indivisible whole, while duality recognizes the distinctions through which we perceive and experience it. The observer and the observed, the self and the other, the countless forms and relationships of Life—all appear distinct, yet none exists independently of Existence.

The difficulty arises when we attempt to confine what IS within the limitations of our descriptions. Calling it One does not eliminate its diversity. Calling it Two does not divide its essential unity. Neither description can encompass its entirety.

In our everyday lives, we frequently become entangled in arguments over definitions, identities, and differing perceptions. We may spend more effort defending our understanding than attending to what is actually before us.

Kabir's response is neither an invitation to abandon inquiry nor a demand to accept another philosophical position. It is a reminder that Reality does not change to accommodate our descriptions of It.

Let It be what It is.

Understanding may continue to evolve. Existence needs no revision.


21-Nov-2026

More by : Rajender Krishan

Top | Doha | Home

Views: 46      Comments: 0


(will not be published)
1500 characters left
Can't read? Reload
Please fill the above code for verification.

Index of Dohas in English

  1. Watching the Grinding Mill Turn
  2. I Went Searching for the Wicked
  3. Tomorrows Work Do Today
  4. Speak Such Words
  5. Slowly, Slowly, O Mind
  6. O Lord, Grant Me Enough
  7. In vain is the eminence
  8. Like sesame contains the oil
  9. Begging is like perishing
  10. Neither illusion nor the mind
  11. Kabira in the market place
  12. Kabir's mind got cleansed
  13. Reading books everyone died
  14. In anguish everyone
  15. Guru is the washerman
  16. While Alive, Understand
  17. Inexpressible is the story of Love
  18. Worry is the Bandit
  19. Don't Be So Proud and Vain
  20. Beware! Be Aware!!
  21. By my doing nothing happens
  22. Like the pupil in the eye
  23. When you were born
  24. First the pangs of separation
  25. With the Ocean Set Ablaze
  26. Kabir, Accumulate the Wealth...
  27. Hope lives in a dying world
  28. If I say one, It is not
  29. Kabir, This is the Abode of Love
  30. The Rosary rotating by the hand
  31. Eons have passed whirling rosary
  32. The rosary made of wooden
  33. When I was then Hari was not
  34. Ages have passed shaving
  35. What Harm have the Hair Done
  36. Arise from slumber O Kabir
  37. O Kabir, Your Hut
  38. He alone's the Warrior
  39. Guru the Potter ...
  40. Liberation Comes Not in Seclusion
  41. Both Guru and Gobind (God) are One
  42. I am the Worst of All
  43. That Death the World is Terrified of
  44. Kabir, When One Died; Two Were Dead ...
  45. That death the world (Another Perspective)
  46. Kabir! Let yourself be a pebble
  47. Maya Has Enticed You
  48. World of Black Soot
  49. Discarding Materialism is Insignificant
  50. The World has Turned a Stone into a God
  51. The bamboo is drowned
  52. Kabir, Why Remain Aleep?
  53. If I say One, It is not
  54. Kabir, The True Warrior is one
  55. Kabira, Your Hut Stands ...